11 Private Island Resorts Accessible to the Public

10. Musha Cay — group-rental private island in the Exumas

Musha Cay is a private-island property in the Exumas that typically is rented out to groups or families as a whole-island experience. Owned and managed with a strong events and private-charter focus, Musha Cay provides full staffing, activities, and customized itineraries, but the booking model differs from per-villa resorts: you generally reserve the entire island for your party. Access usually involves reaching Great Exuma by plane and then taking a private boat or seaplane transfer arranged through the property.