12 Most Overrated Cruise Add-Ons (And What to Book Instead)

2. Unlimited Beverage Packages - When "Unlimited" Has Limits

Beverage packages are among the most controversial cruise add-ons, marketed as convenient ways to enjoy unlimited drinks without worrying about individual charges, yet they come with numerous restrictions and inflated pricing that often makes them poor value propositions. These packages typically cost $50-80 per person per day and promise access to cocktails, wine, beer, specialty coffees, and soft drinks, but the fine print reveals significant limitations including daily drink limits, restricted hours, excluded premium brands, and requirements that all adults in the same cabin must purchase the package. The mathematics rarely work in passengers' favor unless they consume 8-12 alcoholic beverages daily, which is neither healthy nor realistic for most travelers who want to enjoy shore excursions and activities with clear heads. Additionally, many popular drinks are excluded from packages, bartenders may pour lighter drinks to manage costs, and the social pressure to "get your money's worth" can lead to excessive consumption that detracts from the vacation experience. Instead of beverage packages, consider purchasing drinks individually, taking advantage of happy hour specials, bringing allowed beverages onboard (most cruise lines permit wine and soft drinks), exploring local beverages during port visits, and focusing on complimentary options like coffee, tea, water, and juice. Many ships also offer wine by the bottle at reasonable prices, and purchasing a few bottles for special dinners often costs less than daily beverage packages while providing better quality wines.